Earlier this week, as I read about Switzerland bravely outlawing minarets (prayer towers attached to a mosque) the first thing I thought was, “Wow…they should really beef up their security now.”
Then the talk at the yeshiva turned to the subject of whether or not it is good or bad, etc. One of the first points made was that yarmulkes and Jewish prayer shawls are next. Which, to my understanding has already happened to an extent. I had an acquaintance that lived in Holland who said that no outward signs of one’s religion are acceptable in Holland (or maybe the EU?). He couldn’t wear a yarmulke to work, nor wear his Star of David necklace, but the Christians couldn’t wear a crucifix either. This is the face of Socialism…making everyone the same and equal…even though we’re not and never will be.
The case of minarets made someone mention church bells and how those would or should be outlawed to be fair since they are of a similar nature (than the great leap to articles of clothing or jewelry). This in turn sparked a different thought for me entirely. Church bells/steeples and minarets…what attention getters!
For all the similarities among the three religions “of the Book” (with ironically most of the similarities being between Judaism and Islam), Judaism is by far the least imposing. I mean a prayer tower that you use to shout all across the land that it’s time to pray and church bells that sound out all over town? It’s like both are saying, “LOOK AT ME!! I’M HERE!! I’M HERE!!” Judaism on the other hand says, “I’m not here. You don’t see me.”
The oldest of the three faiths seems to have a more mature approach to its own existence. I have often found that often the most insecure people are the ones who crave attention, who seek to legitimize their sense of security by being the life of the party. The two young “upstarts” are very interested in making their impact on the party and go out of their way to gain this popularity. Whereas the “old hat” knows he’s cool…and stands in the corner and waits for the people to come to him (enter image of the Fonz here).
Or could it be something else entirely? Just over two thousand years ago Judaism did proselytize among the nations, and this ended about the time of the destruction of the Second Temple. Since then, after being obliterated and humiliated by Rome, Judaism has suffered her wrath again in the form of Christianity (spiritual Rome). Crusades, inquisitions, pogroms, and the Holocaust have really taken their toll. I think it would make anyone reluctant to step into the world scene and announce “I’M HERE!” Islam also obviously has their share of hate and murder and Jews that live in Muslim lands are very much flying under the radar.
So is Judaism’s approach to the world now a result of centuries of persecution or is it a type of “maturity” and confidence that doesn’t need to be advertised? Maybe a little of both?
